Indian Partnership Act- Dissolution of Partnership

Introduction

So far we have seen how firm is formed, what are rights of partners, how partner can move out of partnership and last how partner can be removed from partnerships. In this article we will discuss how partnership is dissolved.

Chapter 6, from section 39 to 54 deals with dissolution of firm.

Section 39 defines what a dissolution of firms mean. Subsequent sections talks about various methods in which firms can be dissolved.

What is dissolution by the way ?

By the way, it mean termination of relationship of each partner with every other partner. For example there is a firm of three folks, A, B and C. Each of them terminate relationship as to partner then it would be termed as dissolution.

Below are various methods of dissolution of firms.

Dissolution by Agreement (Section 40)

If you get bore of partnership, or business, you all can agree on stopping to do business.
There are two ways to
  1. With consent of all partner: Again, permission of all other partner is required.
  2. In accordance with the contract between the partners: Firm can be dissolved by agreement expressly mentioned in partnership deed. For example, it partnership deed contains the clause that firm can be dissolved by Majority of member by their consent, in this case consent of all partner will not be required.

Compulsory dissolution (Section 41)

Under certain circumstance, firm would have to compulsorily wind up it's business. There are two such scenarios mentioned in section 41.

Related to insolvency : When all member except one become insolvent, then firm has to be compulsorily dissolved. Why ? For example there are 3 partners A, B and C and two of them become insolvent then firm has to be dissolved compulsorily. Can B and C continue if A become solvent ?

When Business become unlawful :  There is NDPS act, which ban trading in Ganjaa. Suppose there is firm Ganjawale,  who trades in marijuana or ganjaa. Now by application or introduction of some law, their business become unlawful, can partners still continue ? In such cases or happening of such events which makes business unlawful, then such partnership will be dissolved.

There is proviso which states that if there are multiple business, and one of them become unlawful, then firm can continue in other business.

Dissolution on happening of certain contingencies (Section 42)

Section 42 have provision related to happening of certain events on which firm is dissolved. Below are four cases it covers

1) Expiration of partnership term : If partnership deed have a clause that partnership will continue for two years, or ends in 31st Dec 2019, then such partnership will be dissolved. What happen if they continue ?

2) Completion of adventure : Say Ambani and Adani, two businessmen come together to build flyover in Mumbai and form a partnership. Once the flyover is constructed, and Modiji inaugurates it with photos, such partnership will be dissolved.
3)Death of partner: If one of the partner dies, technically firm should dissolve. But if other members agree to continue, partnership can be continued.

4)Insolvency of partner : If any partner become insolvent, partnership can be dissolved. But if other partners who are not insolvent want to continue the firm, they can do so.

Dissolution of partnership by notice. (Section 43)

We have discussed partnership at will in section 7. It's a partnership where there is no clarity as to when partnership will end. 

In such partnership, it partner is not in mood, then he can give a notice to other firms regarding dissolution of partnership.

Dissolution of partnership by Court. (Section 44)

There are 7 scenarios under which partnership can be dissolved.

1) Unsoundness of mind : When any partner cannot take rational decisions or has become unsound, then other partner or any friend of partner who became unsound can file a suit for dissolution.

2)Permanent incapacity to perform duties: In Whitewell V Arthur, court held the there should be permanent disability to dissolve the firm. For example A and B formed partnership, where A was conferred administrative and accounting duties. If A is unable to perform those duties for some reason, then B can file a suit for dissolution of the firm.

3)Conduct Injurious to the partnership business : If partner acts in some ways in which it would harm partnership business, then other partner can dissolve the firm.

There is recent example in this regard. Three filmmaker had partnership. (Anurag Kashyap of Gangs of Wasseypur was one of them). One of the partner was accused in sexual assault in #metoo movement. The firm was dissolved because conduct of partner was injurious to partnership.

4)Persistent Breach of partnership agreement : If partner is deliberately doing stupid acts which are in breach of agreement about partnership, then other partner can file for suit for dissolution of firm.

For example, if one partner again and again and again making false accounting entries, in such scenario the faith and trust is lost and hence other partners can file for a suit.

5)Transfer of whole of partner's interest : As said above, partnership is relationship about trust and faith on each other. If one of the partner transfer all his interest to other partner, how the remaining partner can trust that "other" person or third party. Such situation can be a ground for dissolution of a firm.

6) Loss making business : Partnership is established for sharing of profits. What if there are no profits? For example, firm is in trading business, and because of websites like Flipkart and Amazon, they would never be able to make profits, in such cases partnership can be dissolved.

7)When dissolution is just and equitable :  This clause offers lot of discretion to the court. Do you have any definition for "just" ?

In Abbot V Crump,  one of the partner committed adultery with wife of another partner. Court thought that this is ground for dissolution of partnership. Seriously!!!

 Conclusion

There are tons of methods by which partnership can be dissolved.Literally. Chapter 6 of Indian Partnership act deals with all such methods.


Thanks

Comments

Post a Comment

Followers

Popular posts from this blog

Privileges and Immunities to Administration in Suits

Introduction You know government can enter into contracts. Government can start some business. It mean government can sue other people, or you can sue the government. Before you initiate a legal proceedings against government, or even after legal proceedings are initiated, there are some relaxations to government.( OK, we will use Government/Administration as per our discretion interchangeably in this post, but they will mean the same ). So, it might happen that to prove something you may need a document or evidence, but government may be given exemption to produce evidence in that regard. Let's take one example.  General law is that burden of proof is on prosecution. Meaning, the one who accuses other  needs to prove the crime/offence by other. But when government accuses you of Sedition, you have to prove your innocence, burden of proof is on YOU. This is scary, as many times government in power just accuses people of sedition who opposes their ideas/policies, and put oppone...
Read more

Legal History-Administration of Justice in Bombay (1668-1726)

Image
Story About Bombay In 1534, Portuguese acquired Bombay from Local Hindu Raja. Then Bombay was given to King Charles II as dowry in his sister's marriage to in 1661. In 1668 Bombay was given to rent to East India Company for a rent of 10  £ . By today's exchange it would be around 100 Rs. So  yes, Bombay was given on rent to East India Company for the price of 10 Vada-Pav. Administration of Bombay was subordinate to Surat back then. After renting it, company issued a charter in 1668 granting company some rights to make laws to deal with Bombay. Like Administration in Madras, development of Earlier administration could be studied in 3 stages. First Stage: 1670-1683 (Aungier Eara) During this period Bombay was subordinated to Surat. The Governor of Surat was ex-officio Governor of Bombay, though Bombay had Deputy Governor and Council. Gerald Aungier brought some changes in Administration of justice. Two plans, i.e plan of 1670 and plan of 1672 made progress in so...
Read more

Overview of Appeal in CrPC

Image
Introduction Here is the simplistic hierarchy of the Courts. (JMFC stands for Judicial Magistrate of First Class) Not so serious cases are tackled by Lower courts. Serious cases are tackled by Sessions court.  We humans are not Gods. Courts are presided by humans and its possible that they can make a mistake. They should be remedy to people when courts commits  mistake. One of such remedy is Appeals. Remember this one, you don't have right of Appeal in all the cases even if you feel Court had committed some mistake. Criminal Procedure Code gives a right to appeal in specific circumstance.  CrPC provides circumstance when you CANNOT appeal. Apart from CrPC, constitution also have certain provisions related to Appeal. Specific laws like NIA Act, UAPA Act etc have provided separate procedure of Appeal.   In this post we will cover below things When you CANNOT appeal ? Who can appeal and for What purpose ? Appeals to Sessions Court Appeals to High Court Appeals to Suprem...
Read more